5 Common Mistakes When Hiring a General Contractor in Westchester, NY
Hiring a general contractor is one of the most significant decisions a Westchester, New York homeowner will make. Whether you're planning a new driveway, a masonry project, a roof replacement, or a complete exterior renovation, the contractor you choose will largely determine whether your experience is smooth and successful — or frustrating and costly. Over our 40+ years serving homeowners in Westchester and Westchester County, we've seen the same hiring mistakes repeated again and again. Here's what to avoid.
1. Hiring Based on Price Alone
Getting multiple estimates is always smart, but choosing the lowest bid without further investigation is a common and costly mistake. Extremely low bids can indicate a contractor who cuts corners on materials, skips essential steps in preparation, uses unlicensed subcontractors, or plans to hit you with unexpected change orders mid-project. In Westchester and across New York, construction work requires compliance with local codes and permit requirements — corners cut during installation can result in expensive remediation down the line.
Instead of focusing only on the bottom line, compare estimates based on the scope of work, the quality of materials specified, and the thoroughness of the contractor's assessment. A reputable contractor will take the time to walk your property, ask detailed questions, and provide a detailed written estimate — not just a ballpark figure on a napkin.
2. Not Verifying License and Insurance
In New York State, general contractors are required to carry proper licensing and insurance. Hiring an unlicensed contractor in Westchester or anywhere in Westchester County puts you at serious legal and financial risk. If a worker is injured on your property and the contractor lacks workers' compensation insurance, you could be held liable. Similarly, if work is performed without required permits and inspections, you may have difficulty selling your home or face code violations when you do.
Always ask for proof of license, general liability insurance, and workers' compensation before signing any contract. A reputable contractor like Brazilian Pavers will provide these documents without hesitation.
3. Skipping the Written Contract
Verbal agreements have no place in construction. Without a written contract, disputes about scope, timeline, payment schedule, and materials become nearly impossible to resolve fairly. Your contract should specify the exact work to be performed, materials and products to be used (by brand and specification where possible), payment milestones, project start and estimated completion dates, and a clear process for handling changes to the original scope.
4. Ignoring Online Reviews and References
Google Reviews, Facebook recommendations, and word-of-mouth referrals from neighbors in Westchester are invaluable tools for evaluating a contractor's reputation. Look for contractors with a consistent pattern of 5-star reviews that mention specific projects, professionalism, and positive outcomes. A few negative reviews among many positives is normal — pay attention to how the contractor responded to those reviews. A dismissive or defensive response to criticism is a red flag.
Ask for at least three references from recent jobs in the Westchester or Westchester County area and actually call them. Ask specific questions about communication, timeliness, cleanliness on the job site, and whether the final cost matched the estimate.
5. Failing to Understand the Timeline
Construction projects are subject to weather delays, material availability issues, and the realities of running a crew across multiple jobs. That said, a reliable contractor will give you a realistic timeline and keep you informed of any changes. Be cautious of contractors who promise unrealistically short timelines, as these are often a sign they plan to rush the work or are double-booking jobs.
Before work begins, establish clear communication expectations: how will updates be provided, who is your point of contact, and what is the process if there's a delay? A transparent contractor will welcome these conversations.
Ready to Work with Westchester Most Trusted Contractor?
Brazilian Pavers has served the Westchester, NY community for 40+ years with honesty, quality, and care.
Call (914) 557-4189 for a Free Estimate





